Talk:Mechanical Animals (album)

From MansonWiki, the Marilyn Manson encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Sources[edit]

Scar[edit]

A recent edition added these sentences:

"a crick-like sacrificed figure, like Jesus Christ, who was stabbed in the torso on the cross"

"God removes a rib to make Eve, thus making gender. Before the rib removal, Adam was a female/male. "

I have the following questions:

  • what is "a crick-like figure"? I thought it could be a common trope that I am not aware of, but a google search didn't elucidate me.
  • wasn't Jesus technically pierced in the torso and not stabbed?
  • I don't see the point of the last sentence: if by removing a rib from Adam gender was made, it is implicit that before the removal Adam was genderless. Either case, if we want to be explicit, saying he was "a female/male" does not say much (what does that mean? what is a female/male? A person with both genders? None?), and the proper term would be genderless (if we agree that before the rib removal there was no gender).

MindBoosterNoori (talk) 12:27, 23 December 2024 (UTC)

  1. "crick-like figure" -- not sure about this in your context, but i guess it sounds pretty good describing a person nailed to a cross, if crick is meant to described a crooked body, figure, or body part in general
  2. stabbed is correct. (to my understanding the difference between "stab" and "pierce" in English, stabbing is like hitting with a sharp object making wounds, while piercing is a similar action that making a [needle/spear only?] through-and-through holes)
  3. what i googled says that the "gender" of Adam before the rib was removed depends on how one interprets it: either no gender (intersex?), or both. we can say neither on the debate, but we can put both statements letting anybody else interpret it on their own
in any case, we can put a {{Confirm|...}} template instance if we aren't sure. and we're always free to edit someone else's edits nothing (talk) 15:58, 23 December 2024 (UTC)